[usafshelland]

Has anyone else noticed that Peyton Manning RCs, graded that is, are plummeting like no other? I have one that is now only worth 1/2 the BV as two months ago.

[jheringa09]

Season hasn't started yet! Wanna sell it? =)

[bostonsports1]

Prob from the lockout decreasing prices, wonder if this happened to Brady's Rcs too?

[kolb 4]

Probably due to the neck injury.

[joe callahan13]

Are the ungraded ones plummeting as well? If not- then I would assume it is because there have been a whole bunch more that were graded out pretty high.

For instance- let's assume BV on a one card is $50, and it is $300 for a 9.5, which is 1% of the cards graded in my fictional made up scenario. If 1000 more get sent in and they are all 9.5's, the graded price is going to fall hard because they are a LOT more common than previously thought.

[usafshelland]

Season hasn't started yet! Wanna sell it? =)

I might

---

Are the ungraded ones plummeting as well? If not- then I would assume it is because there have been a whole bunch more that were graded out pretty high.

For instance- let's assume BV on a one card is $50, and it is $300 for a 9.5, which is 1% of the cards graded in my fictional made up scenario. If 1000 more get sent in and they are all 9.5's, the graded price is going to fall hard because they are a LOT more common than previously thought. K

Sounds like my college econ class...supply and demand

[mattfastiggi]

neck surgery got people worried i guess

[usafshelland]

neck surgery got people worried i guess

Its not his first one.... besides, if he retires then the faster to Canton he will go.

[jfrench91]

mannings rookie cards have always been low BV in my opinion

[usafshelland]

mannings rookie cards have always been low BV in my opinion

I think so too, but if you look at Favre and Brady, I think it has to do something with the # of SB rings. Not that the Favre RCs are doing to well either.

However, I am thinking that the pricing has to deal with supply and demand.

I have the 1998 Black Diamond Rookies Peyton Manning, BGS 9.5, 1998 Bowman Chrome Interstate, BGS 9.5, and now the 1998 Bowman Interstate, BGS 9.5. I bought the Black Diamond for $80 (when it was over $200 BV), the Bowman Chrome Interstate for $77 (when it was near a couple of Andrew Jackson's BV), and now the regular Bowman Interstate for $31 (which is still BVing pretty high considering I paid less than 25% BV for it.)

My ultimate goal is to buy two a month, either BGS 9.5/10, PSA 10, or maybe SGC 98s/100s.

---

I think so too, but if you look at Favre and Brady, I think it has to do something with the # of SB rings. Not that the Favre RCs are doing to well either.

However, I am thinking that the pricing has to deal with supply and demand.

I have the 1998 Black Diamond Rookies Peyton Manning, BGS 9.5, 1998 Bowman Chrome Interstate, BGS 9.5, and now the 1998 Bowman Interstate, BGS 9.5. I bought the Black Diamond for $80 (when it was over $200 BV), the Bowman Chrome Interstate for $77 (when it was near a couple of Andrew Jackson's BV), and now the regular Bowman Interstate for $31 (which is still BVing pretty high considering I paid less than 25% BV for it.)

My ultimate goal is to buy two a month, either BGS 9.5/10, PSA 10, or maybe SGC 98s/100s.

It must be a football thing or seasonal thing... the 1984 Topps Dan Marino RC BGS 9.5 just dropped $400 in BV! Holy smokes!