07-25-2012, 07:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-25-2012, 07:44 PM by pyweed.)
RE: 2012 Bowman Platinum 5 case break and contest thread [CONTEST #1 CLOSED]
RE: 2012 Bowman Platinum 5 case break and contest thread [CONTEST #1 CLOSED]
Case #1, Box #2
Notable colored base:
Joe Mauer gold
Dustin Pedroia gold
Eric Hosmer gold
Justin Verlander emerald
Notable Top Prospects:
Billy Hamilton
Mason Williams
Taylor Lindsey Green Refractor /399
Mike Olt Blue Refractor /199
Robbie Ray Prospect Auto
Joe Terdoslavich Prospect Auto
James Paxton Auto Relic redemption
Grade: C
Comments: Okay, this is a little closer to what I was expecting. The Terdoslavich may turn out to be a solid base prospect auto card, but I doubt Ray will be a big seller. I have no clue about the Paxton. Adding everything up I think I got about what I paid for. Incidentally, Arcia (from box #1) is the prospect auto to beat in the contest. I’m not sure there will be another blue or lower prospect auto in this case.
[IMG][/IMG]
I agree -- the retail breaks have been pretty scary.
Case #1, Box #3
Notable colored base:
Troy Tulowitzki gold
Adam Jones gold
Chipper Jones gold
Alex Rodriguez emerald
Notable prospect parallels:
Brian Dozier refractor
Guillermo Pimentel refractor
Sean Buckley refractor
Miguel Sano xfractor
Notable die-cut:
Jose Bautista
Notable Top Prospects:
Oscar Taveras
Jean Segura
Mason Williams
Trey McNutt Green Refractor /399
Tyler Skaggs Blue Refractor /199
Tyler Collins Prospect Auto
Vinnie Catricala Green Prospect Auto /399
Brett Lawrie Auto Relic
Grade: A+
Comments: Maybe I’m totally missing the boat, but I felt like I was doing just fine with this box even without the Lawrie relic auto. I see this as a pretty big hit, even unnumbered. Maybe these will turn out to be really common, but my tentative evaluation is that this is an A+ box.
[IMG][/IMG]
Notable colored base:
Joe Mauer gold
Dustin Pedroia gold
Eric Hosmer gold
Justin Verlander emerald
Notable Top Prospects:
Billy Hamilton
Mason Williams
Taylor Lindsey Green Refractor /399
Mike Olt Blue Refractor /199
Robbie Ray Prospect Auto
Joe Terdoslavich Prospect Auto
James Paxton Auto Relic redemption
Grade: C
Comments: Okay, this is a little closer to what I was expecting. The Terdoslavich may turn out to be a solid base prospect auto card, but I doubt Ray will be a big seller. I have no clue about the Paxton. Adding everything up I think I got about what I paid for. Incidentally, Arcia (from box #1) is the prospect auto to beat in the contest. I’m not sure there will be another blue or lower prospect auto in this case.
[IMG][/IMG]
(07-25-2012, 07:11 PM)petercopp Wrote: Sweet box! I have three hobby boxes to bust tonight and I hope they are that good. I have seen a few boxes opened (all hobby) and they have all been pretty good. I have not really seen anybody bust one yet and feel like they got screwed. Retail on the other hand has been hit and miss from what I am seeing but overall, it appears to be a really nice product. Think I am going to put this set together. Good luck on the rest of your breaks, you got a long way to go!
I agree -- the retail breaks have been pretty scary.
Case #1, Box #3
Notable colored base:
Troy Tulowitzki gold
Adam Jones gold
Chipper Jones gold
Alex Rodriguez emerald
Notable prospect parallels:
Brian Dozier refractor
Guillermo Pimentel refractor
Sean Buckley refractor
Miguel Sano xfractor
Notable die-cut:
Jose Bautista
Notable Top Prospects:
Oscar Taveras
Jean Segura
Mason Williams
Trey McNutt Green Refractor /399
Tyler Skaggs Blue Refractor /199
Tyler Collins Prospect Auto
Vinnie Catricala Green Prospect Auto /399
Brett Lawrie Auto Relic
Grade: A+
Comments: Maybe I’m totally missing the boat, but I felt like I was doing just fine with this box even without the Lawrie relic auto. I see this as a pretty big hit, even unnumbered. Maybe these will turn out to be really common, but my tentative evaluation is that this is an A+ box.
[IMG][/IMG]