[jblaze1718]

Go back to xbox and get EA MVP 2005!

[jhyde77]

I played 2K at Best Buy and hated it. Go with The Show.

[seattlefan29]

I hate 2k baseball games. Especially this year... Go with The Show 11. It wont dissapoint. The Show 10 is AMAZING and 11 is gonna be way more epic.

[phillyfan54]

I had 2k last year for Xbox and liked it but I bought q PS3 recently because my xbox broke and will try The Show this year. I download the demo for The Show and as of now I find it very difficult to hit. I imagine I'll get much better. I only play sports games and get bored quick with playing vs the cpu so maily just play online. I'm tempted to get 2k because Halladay is on the cover but from what I've read online The Show does blow 2k away.

[filipizo]

Being an Xbox owner, I don't have a choice. MLB2k9 was so buggy it was unplayable and MLB2k10 was improved but was still very rough around the edges. I hoping 2k11 is good but I am going to hold off buying it till all the user reviews roll in. Stick with the Show if you have a PS3, no doubt.

[alfredoleal2001]

The Show but by farrrrrr!!!!! LOL

[erhofer]

The Show is the game to get, you'll love that game...

[bvander10]

My son love MLB Show for Ps3... Can't get him away from it

[jmilitano]

I only have the 360, so I am stuck with 2k. Its a decent game and the franchise is sufficient, probably completed 3 or 4 seasons, playing every game except the allstar game. I would like to get a ps3 and The Show, as I heard it is much better than 2k.

[christophercox20]

My Friend works for 2k sports and he sends me games for free and last year I asked him this question which one is better and he said the show. So If a employee for 2k says the show then that should be your answer