Beckett Message Boards
Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - Printable Version

+- Beckett Message Boards (https://www.beckett.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Hobby Talk (https://www.beckett.com/forums/forum-1.html)
+--- Forum: Football (https://www.beckett.com/forums/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading (/thread-1495384.html)

Pages: 1 2

Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - brentboudreaux1 - 04-09-2012

Im thinking about having my high end rookies graded and would love for you guys to take a look at these to think if any will grade 8.5 or above. It really doesnt matter bc they are pc and i wont sell....i want to just have them slabbed for protection...but want your expert opinions on what you guys/gals think they will grade at. Thanks in advance. Scans coming shortly.
[Image: DSC_0109_1029.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0110_1030.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0113_1033.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0114_1034.jpg]

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - branesergen - 04-09-2012

The SPx I would say you might pull a 9 depending on surface. The other I would say 7-8 because of the chipping on the back and the scarring near the number.

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - brentboudreaux1 - 04-09-2012

(04-09-2012, 09:35 AM)branesergen Wrote: The SPx I would say you might pull a 9 depending on surface. The other I would say 7-8 because of the chipping on the back and the scarring near the number.

yea, its a reality check when you see your cards up close lol
[Image: DSC_0115_1035.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0116_1036.jpg]

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - giantfan270 - 04-09-2012

The back of that second card isn't going to grade well. You can always label them " minimum grade 8.5 or authenticate only " . Then they are getting slabbed either way.

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - brentboudreaux1 - 04-09-2012

[Image: DSC_0111_1031.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0112_1032.jpg]
(04-09-2012, 09:39 AM)giantfan270 Wrote: The back of that second card isn't going to grade well. You can always label them " minimum grade 8.5 or authenticate only " . Then they are getting slabbed either way.

yea thats what i think i want to do...i shot you a pm Smile

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - giantfan270 - 04-09-2012

The /250 looks like it has been shaved????

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - brentboudreaux1 - 04-09-2012

(04-09-2012, 09:42 AM)giantfan270 Wrote: The /250 looks like it has been shaved????

i hope not! Sad what makes you think that?
[Image: DSC_0117_1037.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0118_1038.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0119_1039.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0120_1040.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0121_1041.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0122_1042.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0125_1045.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0126_1046.jpg]

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - giantfan270 - 04-09-2012

(04-09-2012, 09:40 AM)brentboudreaux1 Wrote: [Image: DSC_0111_1031.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0112_1032.jpg]

yea thats what i think i want to do...i shot you a pm Smile

the back right edge looks like it went through a cutter to me...



RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - brentboudreaux1 - 04-09-2012

[Image: DSC_0123_1043.jpg]
[Image: DSC_0124_1044.jpg]

RE: Need help from those of you with an eye for grading - philly eagle in az - 04-09-2012

I would jsut get them slabbed in the "Authentic" slab. I'll show you my Vick when I get home.